Bulugh al-Maram
Book 2, Hadith 195
وَعَنْ عُثْمَانَ بْنِ أَبِي الْعَاصِ - رضى الله عنه - { أَنَّهُ قَالَ : يَا رَسُولَ اَللَّهِ اِجْعَلْنِي إِمَامَ قَوْمِي . قَالَ : "أَنْتَ إِمَامُهُمْ , وَاقْتَدِ بِأَضْعَفِهِمْ , وَاِتَّخِذْ مُؤَذِّنًا لَا يَأْخُذُ عَلَى أَذَانِهِ أَجْرًا } أَخْرَجَهُ اَلْخَمْسَةُ , وَحَسَّنَهُ اَلتِّرْمِذِيُّ , وَصَحَّحَهُ اَلْحَاكِمُ . 11 - صحيح . رواه أبو داود (531) ، والترمذي (209) ، وابن ماجه (714) ، وأحمد (4/21و217) ، والحاكم (1/199و201) . وقال الترمذي : حسن كما نقل الحافظ عنه ، ويتأيد نقل الحافظ بنقل غيره من الأئمة الآخرين كالنووي ، والزيلعي، والمزي وغيرهم ، إلا أنه في بعض النسخ التي اعتمد عليها الشيخ أحمد شاكر -رحمه الله- قول الترمذي : "حسن صحيح" . ولم أجد ما يؤيد ذلك إلى الآن. فالله أعلم . قلت : ولفظ وطريق الحديث عند الترمذي ، وابن ماجه يختلف عنه عند الباقين ، ولم يكن يحسن من الحافظ -رحمه الله- العزو لهم كلهم هكذا إجمالا .
Uthman ibn Abi al-As said: ‘Messenger of Allah, appoint me as the imam of my people.’ He replied: ‘You are their imam. Take the weakest of them into account, and appoint a caller to prayer who takes no payment for his call.’ Reported by the five compilers; al-Tirmidhi graded it hasan, and al-Hakim graded it sahih.
Authentic. Reported by Abu Dawud (531), al-Tirmidhi (209), Ibn Majah (714), Ahmad (4/21 and 217), and al-Hakim (1/199 and 201). Al-Tirmidhi said ‘hasan,’ as al-Hafiz transmitted from him; this is supported by other imams, including al-Nawawi, al-Zayla‘i, and al-Mizzi. Some copies relied upon by Shaykh Ahmad Shakir read ‘hasan sahih,’ but I have found nothing so far to support that. Allah knows best. I say: The wording and chain in al-Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah differ from those in the other sources, and al-Hafiz should not have attributed it collectively to all of them in this general way.
Translation notes
The source first summarizes the hadith and then provides a detailed bibliographical and grading note. ‘Al-Khamsah’ is rendered as ‘the five compilers’ without inferring their names.
ويتأيد نقل الحافظ بنقل غيره من الأئمة الآخرين
The English witness omits the source's detailed grading and reference note.
Should the witness include the source's full scholarly note?