Bulugh al-Maram
Book 4, Hadith 7
وَعَنْ بَهْزِ بْنِ حَكِيمٍ, عَنْ أَبِيهِ, عَنْ جَدِّهِ قَالَ: قَالَ رَسُولُ اَللَّهِ - صلى الله عليه وسلم -{ فِي كُلِّ سَائِمَةِ إِبِلٍ: فِي أَرْبَعِينَ بِنْتُ لَبُونٍ, لَا تُفَرَّقُ إِبِلٌ عَنْ حِسَابِهَا, مَنْ أَعْطَاهَا مُؤْتَجِرًا بِهَا فَلَهُ أَجْرُهُ, وَمَنْ مَنَعَهَا فَإِنَّا آخِذُوهَا وَشَطْرَ مَالِهِ, عَزْمَةً مِنْ عَزَمَاتِ رَبِّنَا, لَا يَحِلُّ لِآلِ مُحَمَّدٍ مِنْهَا شَيْءٌ } رَوَاهُ أَحْمَدُ, وَأَبُو دَاوُدَ, وَالنَّسَائِيُّ, وَصَحَّحَهُ اَلْحَاكِمُ, وَعَلَّقَ اَلشَّافِعِيُّ اَلْقَوْلَ بِهِ عَلَى ثُبُوتِه ِ 1 .1 - حسن. رواه أبو داود ( 1575 )، والنسائي ( 5 / 15 - 17 و 25 )، وأحمد ( 5 / 2 و4 )، وصححه الحاكم ( 1 / 398 ). قلت: وأما تعليق الشافعي القول به على صحته، فقد رواه البيهقي في "السنن الكبرى" وذلك لرأيه في بهز، ولكن لا عبرة بذلك مع توثيق ابن معين، وابن المديني، والنسائي لبهز، وهم أئمة هذا الشأن. وأما ابن حبان فقد هول في كلامه عنه فقال في "المجروحين" ( 1 / 194 ): "كان يخطئ كثيرا، فأما أحمد بن حنبل وإسحاق بن إبراهيم رحمهما الله فهما يحتجان به، ويرويان عنه، وتركه جماعة من أئمتنا، ولولا حديث: "إنا آخذوه وشطر إبله عزمة من عزمات ربنا" لأدخلناه في "الثقات" وهو ممن استخير الله عز وجل فيه". وقد تعقب الذهبي -كعادته- ابن حبان، فقال في: "التاريخ" ( 9 / 80 - 81 ): "قلت: على أبي حاتم البستي في قوله هذا مؤاخذات، إحداها: قوله: كان يخطئ كثيرا. وإنما يعرف خطأ الرجل بمخالفة رفاقه له، وهذا فانفرد بالنسخة المذكورة، وما شاركه فيها ولا له في عامتها رفيق، فمن أين لك أنه أخطأ؟! الثاني: قولك: تركه جماعة، فما علمت أحدا تركه أبدا، بل قد يتركون الاحتجاج بخبره، فهلا أفصحت بالحق؟! الثالث: ولولا حديث: "إنا آخذوها...." فهو حديث انفرد به أصلا ورأسا، وقال بعض المجتهدين.... وحديثه قريب من الصحة ".
Bahz ibn Hakim reported from his father, from his grandfather, that the Messenger of Allah said: “For every forty freely grazing camels, a bint labun is due. Camels are not to be separated from the count on which their due is calculated. Whoever gives it seeking reward will be rewarded; whoever withholds it, we will take it and half of his property as a binding command among the commands of our Lord. Nothing of it is lawful for the family of Muhammad.” Ahmad, Abu Dawud, and al-Nasa'i transmitted it. Al-Hakim graded it sahih, and al-Shafi'i made acting on it conditional on its authenticity.
The editor grades it hasan and cites Abu Dawud 1575, al-Nasa'i 5:15–17 and 25, Ahmad 5:2 and 5:4, and al-Hakim 1:398. The editor explains that al-Bayhaqi recorded al-Shafi'i's reservation about acting on the report because of his view of Bahz, but considers it outweighed by the endorsements of Bahz by Yahya ibn Ma'in, Ali ibn al-Madini, and al-Nasa'i, leading authorities in hadith criticism. Ibn Hibban strongly criticized Bahz in al-Majruhin 1:194: he said Bahz made many mistakes, although Ahmad ibn Hanbal and Ishaq ibn Ibrahim relied on and transmitted from him; some leading scholars left him; and were it not for the report “We will take it and half his camels as a binding command among the commands of our Lord,” Ibn Hibban would have included him among the trustworthy, though he still regarded him as a narrator about whom he sought Allah's guidance. Al-Dhahabi responded to Ibn Hibban in al-Tarikh 9:80–81, raising three objections: a narrator's error is established by contradiction from his peers, yet Bahz was alone in transmitting the cited collection and had no peers in most of it, so how could Ibn Hibban know it contained errors? Ibn Hibban claimed that a group abandoned Bahz, but al-Dhahabi knew of no one who had abandoned him; scholars may decline to rely on a report without rejecting its narrator, and should say so plainly. Finally, the report about taking the property was unique to Bahz, and some jurists still used it; al-Dhahabi judged Bahz's hadith close to authentic.