The Book of Divorce - Sahih Muslim 1474c

This narration from 'Urwa ibn al-Zubayr through the same chain of transmitters confirms the authenticity and reliability of the preceding ruling. In Islamic scholarship, multiple chains of transmission (turuq) strengthen a hadith's authenticity and remove doubt regarding its preservation.

Scholarly Commentary

The repetition of this narration through identical transmitters indicates the meticulous care taken by early scholars in preserving Prophetic traditions. When a companion like 'Urwa narrates through established chains, it demonstrates the widespread acceptance of this ruling among the learned companions.

Such corroborating reports serve to eliminate any potential errors in transmission and provide certainty in legal matters, particularly in sensitive issues like divorce where precision in understanding the Prophet's teachings is paramount for proper implementation of Islamic law.

Legal Significance

The confirmation through multiple narrators establishes the ruling as definitive (qat'i) in its authenticity, requiring Muslims to accept it without reservation. This methodological approach ensures the preservation of the Sunnah in its pure form, free from alteration or distortion across generations.